THE WINDOW YOU DON'T KNOW YOU'RE IN

Maysoon SalahMaysoon Salah
April 2026
5 min read
THE WINDOW YOU DON'T KNOW YOU'RE IN

Miami buyers are discovering the Treasure Coast. New construction prices haven't caught up yet. Here's what that means if you move now.

Nobody told me the Treasure Coast would be the story of 2026. It happened quietly — the way all the best real estate plays do.

Here's what I'm watching: Miami-Dade median home price just crossed $650,000. Broward is right behind it. And buyers who got priced out of South Florida started driving north. They found Fort Pierce. They found Port St. Lucie. They found Meritage communities priced at $280,000–$340,000 for brand-new construction.

That's a $300,000 gap. That gap is closing.

The question isn't whether Treasure Coast values will rise. They already are — 8.3% year-over-year in St. Lucie County, per the most recent NAR data. The question is whether you're in before or after the window closes.

**What "the window" actually means**

New construction pricing is set by builders based on their cost basis — land, materials, labor. It's slow to adjust. Resale pricing responds to the market in real time.

Right now, Meritage Homes is pricing homes based on what it cost them to build in 2024–2025. But the demand showing up at those communities? It's 2026 demand. Miami refugees. Remote workers who realized they can live in a 2,100 sq ft new construction home for what they were paying in rent.

When builders figure out that demand has outpaced their pricing model, they raise prices. They've done it before — $10,000 increments, sometimes twice in a quarter.

You are currently ahead of that repricing.

**The specific numbers**

A 3-bedroom, 2-bath Meritage home in the Bent Creek community in Fort Pierce: $292,990. Same square footage in Davie, Broward County (resale, comparable age): $485,000. The Treasure Coast discount is real and it's measurable.

The Veranda Gardens community in Port St. Lucie has a 6-week waitlist for its most popular floor plan. Six weeks ago it had no waitlist. That's the velocity indicator.

**What this means if you move now**

If you're a first-time buyer: incentives are still stacked. Meritage is offering $15,000 in closing cost credits on select inventory homes right now. That offer exists because they priced the homes before they saw this demand wave. Once the wave is obvious, the credits go away.

If you're an investor: cap rates on Treasure Coast new construction are running 5.8–6.2% with professional management. That's better than most of coastal Florida. Rent growth is 12% year-over-year in Fort Pierce.

If you're relocating from South Florida: the lifestyle arbitrage is the real story. Same weather. Same access to the water. Same Florida. But your mortgage payment drops by $1,800 a month.

**The honest caveat**

I'm not promising appreciation. Nobody can. But I am telling you what the data shows right now, in April 2026: the people paying attention are moving. The people waiting for certainty will be paying 2027 prices.

The window is open. How long it stays open is the only question I can't answer.

market reportsmarket timingnew constructionTreasure Coast

AI Assistant

Questions about what you just read?

Our AI can go deeper — compare communities, run the numbers, or book a tour.